Ice Cream & Desserts
-
Nana Teresa's Bake Shop
The island's newest bake shop offers a delightful selection of made-from-scratch cupcakes, cookies, pastries, pies, and more. Custom cakes are available for special order.
An authentic 1950s soda fountain brings nostalgic favorites to life, including milkshakes, floats, slushies, sodas, egg creams, and banana splits.
With an endless array of dessert choices—fudge brownies, milkshakes, cupcakes, ice cream sundaes, cheesecake, macaron cookies, and cake slices—there’s something to satisfy every sweet tooth.
-
Vintage Donuts
Vintage Donuts is a must-visit sweet spot on Centre Street in Downtown Fernandina Beach, bringing a nostalgic twist to the island’s food scene. This locally owned shop specializes in made-to-order cake donuts, allowing guests to customize every bite.
With a variety of icings, toppings, and drizzles, visitors can create their own perfect treat or choose from one of their "tasty combos."
Whether grabbing a quick coffee and donut while shopping or picking up a dozen for the family, Vintage Donuts delivers fresh, delicious indulgence with a touch of old-school charm.
-
Thirteen
Located in the Beech Street Shoppes, this dessert bar specializes in an extensive selection of gluten-free treats.
From wedding and special occasion cakes to cheesecakes and more, they offer a delicious array of options for every sweet tooth. Whether celebrating a milestone or simply indulging in a guilt-free dessert, customers can enjoy expertly crafted confections made with high-quality ingredients.
With a commitment to taste and dietary inclusivity, this dessert destination caters to those seeking both classic favorites and innovative creations, ensuring a memorable and satisfying experience for all.
-
Peterbrooke Chocolatier Amelia Island
Amelia Island's local Peterbrooke Chocolatier offers its famous chocolate-covered popcorn, along with a variety of dipped treats, candies, and truffles, all made with high-quality couverture chocolate.
Visitors can browse the store for gift ideas and unique treats for themselves, family, and friends. A dedicated section features beach-themed chocolates, celebrating the natural beauty that makes Amelia Island special.
Hand-selected and artfully decorated gift baskets showcase the delicious chocolates inside, while seasonal customizations ensure the perfect offering for any holiday.
-
The Peach Cobbler Factory
The Peach Cobbler Factory offers an unparalleled selection of desserts all under one roof. Guests can indulge in warm, flavorful cobblers served with ice cream, rich banana puddings, sweet and savory cinnamon rolls, Pudd-N Shakes, Bigger & Better Cookies, and more. These treats can be enjoyed alongside the house-made Sweet Peachy Tea or a refreshing Cold Rush Cold Brew Coffee. Visitors are encouraged to ask their Cobble-Rista about the "BIG Cobbler Cookie of the Week" for a special treat.